Perbandingan · 16 perbedaan material
The Giving Pledge vs Solidaire Network
Perbandingan ini dibuat atas permintaan dari catatan yang ada. Tidak memuat putusan editorial dan tidak diindeks. Perbandingan yang diterbitkan tercantum di halaman perbandingan.
Baca ke bawah setiap kolom untuk satu organisasi, dan ke samping sepanjang satu baris untuk melihat perbedaannya. Tanda bronse di sisi kiri sel berarti organisasi berbeda pada baris tersebut. Tanda hubung atau "tidak dipublikasikan" berarti organisasi tidak mengungkapkan fakta tersebut — bukan berarti nol.
Terverifikasi September 2026
Jaringan filantropi
Terverifikasi September 2026 The Giving Pledge
Individuals and couples with a net worth of at least one billion dollars, or who would be billionaires but for their giving
Jaringan filantropi
Solidaire Network
Individual wealth holders able to move $50,000 or more a year in giving, and professional staff and trustees at grantmaking foundations, who want to direct money toward…
Yang dicatat dalam dokumen
- Minimum net worth — The Giving Pledge: A net worth of at least one billion dollars, or a net worth that would be at that level but for the person's giving; Solidaire Network: No published minimum net worth.
- Geographic restriction — The Giving Pledge: No published geographic restriction; Solidaire Network: United States.
- Annual dues — The Giving Pledge: No membership dues exist. The Giving Pledge states it does not solicit donations or request any administrative or handling charges, and warns that emails seeking payment in its name are scams. The community is operationally hosted by the Gates Foundation.; Solidaire Network: Not publicly disclosed — the membership page states the criteria but routes fee details into separate individual and institutional membership documents hosted off-site, and no figure appears on the site itself..
Berdampingan
| The Giving Pledge | Solidaire Network | |
|---|---|---|
| Profil | ||
| Jenis | Philanthropic network | Philanthropic network |
| Didirikan | 2010 (Founded by Warren Buffett, Melinda French Gates and Bill Gates in 2010; formally announced in June 2010 with 40 initial signatories, all in the United States. The Giving Pledge publishes no office address of its own; it is "a separate but affiliated community operationally hosted by the Gates Foundation", which is based in Seattle.) | 2012 (Sources differ. Wikipedia's article on co-founder Leah Hunt-Hendrix dates the network's founding to 2012; Solidaire's own site says it has been embedded in justice movements "for a decade" and its published timeline begins in 2015. Solidaire Network Inc received its own IRS tax exemption only in May 2020, having previously operated under fiscal sponsorship, so the incorporation date and the founding date are different things.) |
| Kantor pusat | United States | Oakland, United States |
| Geographic footprint | More than 250 signatories in 30 countries, including Hong Kong and Taiwan alongside mainland China; US signatories come from 30 states and the District of Columbia | United States, organised through regional hubs rather than formal chapters; the 2024 network gathering was held in Atlanta |
| Anggota | 250as of September 2026 | Not publicly disclosed — Solidaire publishes no member count. It does state that about 40 per cent of members work as professionals at foundations. |
| Cabang | The Giving Pledge has no chapters. | Solidaire has regional hubs rather than chapters, and does not publish how many. |
| Primary audience | Individuals and couples with a net worth of at least one billion dollars, or who would be billionaires but for their giving | Individual wealth holders able to move $50,000 or more a year in giving, and professional staff and trustees at grantmaking foundations, who want to direct money toward left-of-centre social justice organising |
| Anggota tipikal | Signatories are billionaires and billionaire couples who have publicly committed to give the majority of their wealth to philanthropy during their lifetime or in their wills. Most publish a signed letter explaining their reasoning. A separate Next Generation group, created in 2014, has more than 300 active members worldwide aged 18 to 75, drawn from the children and grandchildren of signatories; their identities are not disclosed because they did not personally sign the pledge. | Individual members are people with wealth who can generally move $50,000 or more in annual giving, whether personally or through a family foundation, donor-advised fund or family office, and who are aligned with Solidaire's stated values. Institutional members are foundation professionals: Solidaire says about 40 per cent of its membership works at foundations of all sizes. The joining form also names donor advisors, money coaches, current and prospective foundation trustees and philanthropy-serving organisation staff as relevant categories. |
| Qualification | ||
| Kekayaan bersih minimum | A net worth of at least one billion dollars, or a net worth that would be at that level but for the person's givingApplies to individuals and couples.verified September 2026 · sumber ↗ | No published minimum net worth |
| Pembatasan geografis | No published geographic restriction | United StatesOrganised through regional hubs; the annual network gathering is held in person in a US city.verified September 2026 · sumber ↗ |
| Invitation required | Sometimes | No |
| Sponsor required | No | Not documented |
| Application process | Someone who meets the billionaire threshold and is ready to make the public commitment contacts the Giving Pledge to express interest. There is no published application form, review committee, sponsorship requirement or interview stage. In the early years Gates, French Gates and Buffett recruited signatories directly. Signatories usually publish a letter on the Giving Pledge website when they join. | Prospective members complete an interest form on the membership page, indicating which categories apply to them and how they heard about Solidaire. The donor organising and philanthropic transformation teams then follow up. Separate individual and institutional membership documents are linked from the page. New members receive an orientation packet. Solidarity Circles are joined by separate application. |
| Selectivity | Not publicly disclosed — no acceptance rate or vetting process is published. The threshold is the billion-dollar net worth test plus willingness to make the commitment publicly. | Not publicly disclosed — no acceptance rate or review process is published. The effective filters are the $50,000 giving-capacity expectation and alignment with Solidaire's stated political principles. |
| Biaya | ||
| Iuran Tahunan | No membership dues exist. The Giving Pledge states it does not solicit donations or request any administrative or handling charges, and warns that emails seeking payment in its name are scams. The community is operationally hosted by the Gates Foundation.verified September 2026 · sumber ↗ | Not publicly disclosed — the membership page states the criteria but routes fee details into separate individual and institutional membership documents hosted off-site, and no figure appears on the site itself.verified September 2026 · sumber ↗ |
| Biaya inisiasi | No joining fee.verified September 2026 · sumber ↗ | Not publicly disclosedverified September 2026 |
| Biaya Acara | The Giving Pledge publishes no dues or fees of any kind; there are none. | Not publicly disclosed — the annual network gathering's cost is not published.verified September 2026 |
| Membership term | Permanent — the pledge is a lifetime and testamentary commitment | Not documented |
| Struktur | ||
| Meeting frequency | An annual gathering for signatories, plus smaller gatherings, learning sessions, cohort programmes and multi-day trips through the year, including sessions for signatories' family members and philanthropic staff | Biweekly virtual member meetings (Beloved Fridays), Solidarity Circles meeting on their own schedules, regional hub gatherings in person and online, drop-in philanthropic transformation caucuses, and one in-person network gathering a year |
| Peer forums | No standing confidential peer forums are published. The Giving Pledge team convenes small-group cohorts, full-day sessions and multi-day learning trips, and runs a separate Next Generation group for signatories' children and grandchildren. | Solidarity Circles — member-driven groups formed around a topic, meeting on their own schedule for a duration the group sets — plus regional hubs and identity- or role-based philanthropic transformation caucuses. Members also run a rapid-response giving listserv for member-led resource mobilisations. |
| Confidentiality | Signatories' identities and letters are public by design. The Next Generation group is the exception: the Giving Pledge does not disclose its members' identities, on the grounds that they did not personally choose to sign. | Not publicly disclosed |
| Time commitment | Not documented | Not documented |
| Organized as | Event-focused, Virtual | Event-focused, Virtual, Chapter-based, Forum-based |
| Forum sejawat rahasia | Partial | Yes |
| Cabang-cabang lokal | No | Yes |
| Keanggotaan virtual | Not documented | Yes |
| Komunitas daring | Partial | Yes |
| Direktori anggota | Yes | Partial |
| Acara | Yes | Yes |
| Pemrograman | ||
| Program pendidikan | Yes | Yes |
| Pengembangan kepemimpinan | No | Yes |
| Retret | Not documented | Yes |
| Perjalanan | Not documented | No |
| Program keluarga | Partial | Partial |
| Program untuk pasangan | Yes | Not documented |
| Program generasi berikutnya | Yes | Partial |
| Diskusi investasi | No | Partial |
| Peluang investasi | No | No |
| Komponen filantropi | Yes | Yes |
| Penekanan pada jaringan | Medium | High |
| Penekanan sosial | Low | Medium |
Berikutnya
Terakhir diverifikasi: belum ditinjau
Laporkan kesalahan pada halaman ini
Sumber
Diambil dari sumber yang tercantum di setiap halaman: The Giving Pledge · Solidaire Network