مقارنة · 23 فوارق جوهرية
HBR Advisory Council vs Helm
هذه المقارنة مُولَّدة عند الطلب من السجلات. لا تحمل حكمًا تحريريًا وغير مفهرسة. المقارنات المنشورة مدرجة في صفحة المقارنة.
اقرأ كل عمود لاستيعاب منظمة واحدة، واقرأ عبر الصف لترى الفارق. تعني العلامة البرونزية على يسار الخلية أن المنظمات تختلف في ذلك الصف. الشرطة أو عبارة "غير منشور" تعني أن المنظمة لا تُفصح عن تلك المعلومة؛ وهي ليست صفراً.
موثَّق September 2026
مجتمع بالدعوة فقط
موثَّق September 2026 HBR Advisory Council
Harvard Business Review readers, mainly managers and executives, invited to give structured feedback to HBR's editors
مجتمع بالدعوة فقط
Helm
Founders and CEOs of UK scale-up businesses past about £3 million in revenue
ما تفيد به السجلات
- Role or title: HBR Advisory Council: No published role or title; Helm: Founder or CEO of the business.
- Minimum company revenue: HBR Advisory Council: No published minimum company revenue; Helm: £3m+ revenue, or more than £3m raised.
- Minimum employees: HBR Advisory Council: No published minimum employees; Helm: Team size around 20 full-time equivalents.
- Geographic restriction: HBR Advisory Council: No published geographic restriction; Helm: United Kingdom scale-up businesses.
- Annual dues: HBR Advisory Council: $0 a year; Helm: £1,450 a year.
مقارنة جنباً إلى جنب
| HBR Advisory Council | Helm | |
|---|---|---|
| الملف الشخصي | ||
| النوع | Invitation-only community | Invitation-only community |
| تأسّس | Not documented | 2003 (Founded as The Supper Club in 2003 by Duncan Cheatle; rebranded to Helm. Helm's own site states the 2003 founding on every page footer line and in its FAQ.) |
| المقر الرئيسي | Boston, United States | London, United Kingdom |
| Geographic footprint | Online reader and research panel with no chapters or local groups | United Kingdom: events across London and regional UK hubs, plus a digital community; Helm does not publish a full list of hubs |
| الأعضاء | Not publicly disclosed | 400as of September 2026 |
| الفروع | No chapters | Helm has no chapters. It runs Forum groups and events in London and regional UK hubs but does not publish a hub list or a Forum count. |
| Primary audience | Harvard Business Review readers, mainly managers and executives, invited to give structured feedback to HBR's editors | Founders and CEOs of UK scale-up businesses past about £3 million in revenue |
| العضو النموذجي | Not publicly disclosed. HBR publishes no eligibility criteria, seniority test or member profile for the Advisory Council; membership is by invitation. | Members are founders and CEOs of UK scale-ups, with average member turnover of about £21 million according to Helm's own comparison page. Businesses span SaaS, deep tech, biotech, property, manufacturing and retail. Non-founder executives, advisers and service providers are explicitly not admitted. |
| Qualification | ||
| الدور أو المسمى الوظيفي | No published role or title | Founder or CEO of the business"non-founder executives, advisers and service providers are not admitted as members".verified September 2026 · المصدر ↗ |
| الحد الأدنى لإيرادات الشركة | No published minimum company revenue | £3m+ revenue, or more than £3m raisedHelm's published qualification panel: "Revenue £3m+ (or, raised >£3m)".verified September 2026 · المصدر ↗ |
| الحد الأدنى لعدد الموظفين | No published minimum employees | Team size around 20 full-time equivalentsHelm's qualification panel gives "Team size 20 FTEs"; its FAQ says "a team of around 20 or more".verified September 2026 · المصدر ↗ |
| القيد الجغرافي | No published geographic restriction | United Kingdom scale-up businessesverified September 2026 · المصدر ↗ |
| Invitation required | Yes | No |
| Sponsor required | No | No |
| Application process | There is no application. HBR invites readers to join the Advisory Council and the FAQ does not describe any way to request an invitation. Members can leave at any time using the unsubscribe link in a council email. | A short application form (Helm says two to five minutes), then a 30-minute qualifying call with the membership team to check fit and identify a suitable Forum. Helm describes committee approval within about 48 hours, followed by a 45-minute onboarding call. Forum placement follows an introductory conversation with the prospective Forum Chair and happens within one to three months of joining. |
| Selectivity | Not publicly disclosed. HBR states only that membership is currently by invitation. | No acceptance rate is published. Helm states that every application is reviewed for fit and that non-founder executives, advisers and service providers are not admitted. |
| التكلفة | ||
| الرسوم السنوية | $0 a yearNo membership fee is charged or mentioned anywhere in the Advisory Council pages or FAQ; the council is a research panel rather than a paid membership.verified September 2026 · المصدر ↗ | £1,450 a yearClub membership: "£1,450 /per annum" on Helm's Get Started page. In-person experiences are pay-as-you-go at this tier.verified September 2026 · المصدر ↗ |
| الرسوم الشهرية | HBR does not charge for Advisory Council membership. Members receive downloadable content, and on some projects the final research report, in exchange for survey participation. | £495 a monthA Helm comparison landing page quotes "£495 Joining Fee + £495 per month" (about £5,940 a year), which conflicts with the annual figures on the Get Started page. Both are Helm's own pages; the discrepancy is unresolved.verified September 2026 · المصدر ↗ |
| رسوم الانضمام | HBR does not charge for Advisory Council membership. Members receive downloadable content, and on some projects the final research report, in exchange for survey participation. | £495 one-time"£495 Joining Fee" per Helm's comparison landing page. No joining fee appears on the Get Started page.verified September 2026 · المصدر ↗ |
| Membership term | Open-ended; members leave by unsubscribing | Annual, cancellable at any time under the published membership agreement |
| الهيكل | ||
| Meeting frequency | Research invitations, generally no more than one survey per month | Forum meets ten times a year (about three hours a month) plus an annual retreat; Helm runs two to three events a week, roughly 160 a year |
| Peer forums | No forums | Chaired Forum groups of six to eight founders, capped at eight, matched on business size, experience level, personality mix and Chair expertise; Chairs are experienced or exited founders |
| Confidentiality | Research is conducted by Beehive Research Ltd, which HBR states is registered with the Market Research Society and ESOMAR | Events run under the Chatham House Rule; Forum is described as absolutely confidential ("What's discussed at Helm stays at Helm") |
| Time commitment | Roughly one optional survey a month at most, per the FAQ | About three hours a month for Forum; Helm states there is no fixed overall commitment and that members typically attend an event every one to two months |
| Organized as | Virtual | Forum-based, Event-focused, Virtual |
| منتديات الأقران السرية | No | Yes |
| الفصول المحلية | No | Partial |
| العضوية الافتراضية | Yes | Partial |
| مجتمع إلكتروني | No | Yes |
| دليل الأعضاء | No | Yes |
| الفعاليات | No | Yes |
| البرمجة | ||
| البرامج التعليمية | Partial | Yes |
| تطوير القيادة | No | Yes |
| ملتقيات | No | Yes |
| السفر | No | Partial |
| البرامج الأسرية | No | No |
| برامج الزوج والشريك | No | No |
| برامج الجيل القادم | No | No |
| نقاشات الاستثمار | No | Yes |
| الفرص الاستثمارية | No | Partial |
| المكوِّن الخيري | No | Partial |
| التركيز على التواصل | Low | High |
| التركيز الاجتماعي | Low | High |
التالي
آخر تحقق: لم تُراجَع بعد
الإبلاغ عن خطأ في هذه الصفحة
المصادر
مستقاة من المصادر المُدرجة في كل صفحة: HBR Advisory Council · Helm